Interstate 15 cuts straight through Clark County on its way to Montana, so a good portion of what lands on the Dubois misdemeanor calendar comes from highway stops made by Idaho State Police troopers and Clark County deputies. Local incidents in Dubois, Spencer and the outlying ranch country fill out the rest. A magistrate in the Dubois courthouse hears all of it, and the elected Clark County Prosecuting Attorney, or that office's deputy, speaks for the State.

The first hours after arrest

Should deputies jail someone in Dubois without a warrant in hand, a Clark County judge has 48 hours to rule on whether probable cause exists. Idaho also insists that the person see a Clark County magistrate promptly. At that hearing a Dubois magistrate lays out the accusation, mentions the option of court-appointed counsel, and fixes release conditions. Idaho's constitution lets a court deny bail solely for capital charges with strong proof, so travelers and residents charged with misdemeanors in Clark County are usually released on bond or a signed promise to appear.

Requesting a public defender

October 1, 2024 marked the date a new state agency took charge of trial-level indigent defense throughout Idaho. Dubois has no defender office of its own; instead, private attorneys under state contract are assigned Clark County cases. Ask the Dubois clerk for the application, and the magistrate will rule on eligibility and name a contract lawyer when the Clark County applicant qualifies. Clark County residents with questions may dial the agency at (208) 605-4575.

Trial rights and outcomes

After the Clark County defendant pleads not guilty in Dubois, Idaho law gives the State six months to put the Clark County case before a jury. Six Clark County residents form the jury, and nothing short of a unanimous vote convicts or acquits. In practice, most Dubois cases close with a negotiated plea. Clark County magistrates can also withhold judgment, so a Clark County probationer who finishes every condition may later petition the Dubois court for withdrawal of the plea and a Clark County dismissal.

Sentences for misdemeanors in Clark County

• Baseline penalty in Dubois: a Dubois jail term as long as six months and a Clark County fine of as much as $1,000, unless the governing Idaho statute authorizes more (some misdemeanors stretch to twelve months).
• First DUI on I-15 or elsewhere in Clark County: exposure to six months in the Dubois jail and a Clark County fine reaching $1,000, a first month of total license loss, and then a follow-on suspension lasting between two and five months, with limited driving a possibility for Clark County motorists in that span.
• Additional DUI conditions for Clark County drivers: an alcohol evaluation, and ordinarily twelve months of a breath-testing interlock on the vehicle after the suspension.

Dubois misdemeanor files tend to close in anywhere from four weeks to several months.

↑ Back to the question list

Every felony charged in Clark County comes from the county Prosecuting Attorney. Each one opens before a Dubois magistrate and, if probable cause holds up, is handed off to a Seventh District judge. Trafficking cases that grow out of interstate traffic stops are a recurring part of the serious caseload in a county of this kind, alongside burglary, theft and assault.

From complaint to District Court

A Clark County felony is commenced with a complaint, which entitles the accused to have a Dubois magistrate hold a preliminary hearing. The deadline is 14 days for someone still jailed and 21 days for someone already out, though a judge can extend either one for good cause. Clark County's prosecutor can sidestep the hearing altogether by persuading a grand jury to indict. Following bind-over, Clark County's prosecutor lodges an "information," and the Clark County defendant is arraigned by a Seventh District judge; from that date Idaho allows six months to bring a Clark County felony to trial.

Who defends indigent felony clients

A Clark County felony defendant who lacks funds for private counsel gets a contract attorney whose fees the state agency pays. The paperwork is filed with the Dubois clerk, and appointments are made by the judge alone. If a conflict bars the contract lawyer from the case, Idaho's Alternate Counsel Division represents the Clark County defendant.

How felony sentences work in Idaho

A prison sentence handed down in Dubois has two parts under Idaho's unified system: a fixed term served day for day, then an indeterminate term in which release from a Clark County sentence lies with Idaho's parole commission. Judges frequently suspend prison for probation instead, or keep jurisdiction while the Clark County defendant completes a state prison "rider" lasting up to a year, then revisit probation once it ends. Treatment courts in the Seventh District cluster in the larger counties, so a Clark County defendant should ask defense counsel whether any program will take the case. Three felony convictions can make someone a persistent violator facing anywhere from five years to a life term. Twelve Clark County jurors decide a felony trial, unanimously, and a typical Clark County felony needs six to 18 months to reach an outcome.

↑ Back to the question list

A killing, sexual assault or armed robbery is a rare event in Clark County. When one is charged, the Dubois prosecutor generally works hand in hand with state investigators and the Idaho crime laboratory. The paperwork follows the standard felony route through the Clark County courthouse, but bail, sentencing exposure and the calendar all shift dramatically.

Bail and pretrial detention

Under Idaho's constitution, a Clark County judge may deny bail only when a capital charge rests on clear and convincing proof, which in practice means some first-degree murder cases. For any other violent crime, bail is set, though often at sums few Clark County defendants can raise. Custody rests with the Clark County Sheriff, starting at the Dubois jail on West Main; since that jail holds only a handful of people, an extended pretrial stay may be spent in another county's facility under the sheriff's arrangements.

Appointed counsel

A Clark County defendant accused of violence who meets the financial test receives a lawyer from Idaho's state-run defense system, (208) 605-4575; when a conflict exists, Idaho's conflict-counsel unit handles the Clark County file.

Potential punishment

• First-degree murder tried in Dubois: life with at least ten fixed years, or death where prosecutors filed the required notice and the Clark County jury finds an aggravating circumstance.
• Second-degree murder: a ten-year floor and a ceiling of life.
• Rape: one year on the bottom end of the range and life on the top.
• Robbery: not less than five years, potentially life.
• Armed commission: Section 19-2520 of the Idaho Code authorizes a Dubois judge to add 15 years at most when a Clark County felony of the listed kinds involves a firearm or another deadly weapon carried by the Clark County offender.

Victim participation and case length

Idaho's constitution, in Article I, Section 22, provides victims of Clark County crimes notification about upcoming hearings, the right to attend Dubois proceedings, a chance to address the Dubois judge before sentencing, and restitution. Expect a serious violent case in Dubois to take a year at minimum and possibly three, with a capital prosecution taking longer than that.

↑ Back to the question list

Clark County's district courthouse is at 224 West Main, Dubois, ID 83423; the clerk's line is 208-374-5402. Find a Dubois hearing date on the Idaho iCourt case search.

Clark County warrant questions go to 208-374-5403 or the clerk at 208-374-5402.

↑ Back to the question list

• Jail search for Clark: Clark County Inmate Search, or call 208-374-5403.
• VINELink covers Clark and other Idaho jails, with Clark custody status and release notices.
• After a Clark prison sentence: the Idaho Department of Correction Resident/Client Search, and JE's Idaho state prisons guide.
• A Clark federal prisoner: Federal Bureau of Prisons inmate locator.
• Clark County immigration detainee: ICE Online Detainee Locator System.

↑ Back to the question list

Federal crimes charged in Clark County skip the Dubois courthouse. The case belongs to the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho, Eastern Division, 801 E. Sherman St., Pocatello (208-478-4123). The federal magistrate for the Clark case chooses release terms or detention under 18 U.S.C. 3142, and a detention hearing for the Clark defendant may follow within five days. The U.S. Marshals Service holds the Clark defendant before trial, sometimes in a contract county jail; call 208-374-5403 to check the Dubois jail first. After a Clark federal sentence, find the Clark County defendant's prison with the Federal Bureau of Prisons inmate locator.

↑ Back to the question list

1. Booking staff in Dubois check citizenship status under Idaho Code 18-9008 and report a possible Clark noncitizen to Homeland Security within 48 hours.
2. ICE can send the Clark jail a Form I-247A detainer.
3. When the Clark County case is over, Idaho Code 18-9005(4) requires the Clark jail to honor a reasonable detainer.
4. The hold lasts no more than 48 hours, weekends and holidays counted, past the Clark release time.
5. The ICE Idaho Falls office (2075 N Boulevard, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, 208-535-5100) collects the Clark County detainee, often for the Elmore County Detention Center in Mountain Home.
6. Track the Clark detainee on the ICE Online Detainee Locator System with an A-number, or with the Clark detainee's name and birth country.

↑ Back to the question list

1. To appeal a Clark magistrate judgment, the defense has 42 days to file its notice with the Clark County district court (Idaho Criminal Rule 54).
2. Felony appeals from Clark County need a notice within 42 days of judgment (Idaho Appellate Rule 14), and the Supreme Court may hand the Clark appeal to the Court of Appeals.
3. When the Dubois judge appoints it, the State Appellate Public Defender takes on Clark felony appeals for people who cannot pay.
4. A motion to reduce a Clark sentence is due within 120 days after judgment (Idaho Criminal Rule 35).
5. A post-conviction petition in Clark County is due one year after the Clark appeal ends or the appeal deadline passes (Idaho Code 19-4902).
6. A sentenced state prisoner, if in the Clark jail or prison, must meet each Clark County deadline; the Dubois clerk at 208-374-5402 can confirm filing dates.

↑ Back to the question list